The Sikh-Muslim School in the Punjab – Prof Puran Singh

It may not be inappropriate here to refer to a school of Nam-culture in the Punjab that must be so called to distinguish it from the Sufis (The Sufis being the Hindu-Muslim School of thought), the Sikh-Muslim School. It is well-known that Baba Guru Nanak was well-beloved of both Hindus and Muslims. In distant Baghdad, he counted disciples like Shah Behlol. At Mecca, he met Quazi Ruakan Din, the Pir of Uch and the latter bowed down to the Guru, begging of Him his sandals to be kept as relics in his dynasty and those sandals are still there. Farid Sani and others like Pir Makhdum Bahauddin were great devotees of Guru Nanak. Mardana was his disciple, Kamal of Kurham loved and died singing the Guru’s mantram “Glory be to the Guru” ! “Glory be to the Guru” !

And so this intercourse between him and the Muslim mystics became more and more intimate as the Guru’s culture spread. The Hindus recited Japuji, sang the Guru’s name, lived dedicated lives and went great distances to meet him. They gave up caste, and partook of the food at the Guru’s langar. Their doubts and superstitions were dispelled. And they came later on, in Sikh history, to be knows as Sahajdharis. These Hindus had abjured wholly the superstitious sundry faith of Brahminism and had taken shelter in the Guru. They formed the Sikh-Hindu School. The fact that this Sikh-Hindu School has automatically lapsed into Brahminism, however regrettable, shows that any school of new culture in India beset with so many quagmires of sects founded on smaller philosophies and empty dogmas, needs not only spiritual isolation, but physical isolation to live. Few Sahajdharis have survived, while the Sikh with beards and hair forming a kind of physical isolation still respond to the call of the Guru, as despite all their imperfections and poverty they still harbour the Guru’s spark.

In the time of Guru Arjan Dev, both Hindus and Muslims gathered round his person, Meeting him was a culture for all. The following extract from the pen of the Emperor Jahangir form His Memories shows how both Hiindus and Muslims gathered round Guru Arjan Dev, which the Emperor was of course unable to understand and appreciate as the great Akbar had done.

“So many of hte simple-minded Hindus, many many foolish Muslims, too had been fascinated by his ways and teachings. They called him Guru, and form all directions crowds of people would come to him”

The fact that Guru Har Gobind had to shelter a Muslim woman disciple from Lahore to Amritsar, to whom the Sikh name Kaulan was given, shows that there was already a reaction caused in some sections of Mussalmans. They might have been quite few due to political reasons, but the element of Intense devotion to the Guru was there among them. Ordinary surface-history does not record the meeting of the mystic ancestors of Bullah Shah and Waris Shah, but the litrature of these periods of the Punjab is full of internal literary evidence of the language of the Guru being used by these Muslim saints of the Sikh-Muslim School.

A most notable but invisible change had occurred. The Muslem poets of the Punjab gave up their Persian and Urdu in favour of the Punjabi language used by the Guru. Shah Hussain, Bullah Shah and Waris Shah, all belong to this renaissance which followed the influence of Guru Arjan Dev on the mind of his age and the age following immediately after him.

These Punjabi mystics belong to the Sikh-Muslim School, in which though nominally Muslims, they preached the Guru’s religion of love. and the Guru as God enough for the living beings of this earth.

The Punjab of the Gurus, whether Hindu or Sikh or Muslims, is essentially Sikh

Bullah Shah calls Inayat Shah his Sat-Guru. The Sikh has certainly no quarrel with names. It is the process of inspiration which must come to play under any names.

The dedicated and pure life of Sikh men and women must have had its effect all around it; so much so that it must be said that the Punjab of the Gurus, whether Hindu or Sikh or Muslims, is essentially Sikh. The new interpretation of Islam given by Iqbal as love is due to the un-conscious influence of the Guru’s presence in the Punjab. It is my faith, no Punjabi can escape the spiritual hidden effects of this great inspiration.

So also in the Sindh province. In the Punjab of the Gurus came caravans of disciples from Sindh, Kabul and Kandahar, from Baghdad and the Caucasus-Ranges and mingled as multi-coloured humanity in the job of the holy crowds, in the job of seeing him.

This pageant of the whole people made alive by the great magnetic influence of the Guru’s love and inspiration was life giving.

Recently in our days, there was a Muslim fakir in the district of Gujrat (This district is now in Pakistan) in Punjab who would, while going away or returning to his place, alight at Amritsar and pay his visit to the Golden Temple. He used to say, “What must have been the influence of the great Gurus, when after four hundred years, here by touching his marble floor of their temple, one gets the stream of Simrin, ‘Naming him’, so much quickened. The broken ones are united here. No impurity can stay here. A magnetic current of inspiration still flows here. Those who know aught of spiritual life and of Simrin can feel the flow of inspiration”. Such is the testimony of this mystic, evidently not openly of the Sikh School.

There are a hundred more Muslim mystics who practice Guru’s word, “Glory to Him!” “Glory to Him !” They sing “Blessed be Guru Nanak !”

Though history does not trace the social tradition of a decade ago of which I myself have been a child and eyewitness, there has been great amity almost; amounting to kinship as of blood between the Sikhs and the Muslims in the Villages. The other day I went to a village and lived as a the guest of a Muslim family of farmers. Their simple rustic feeling and service reminded me of the Sikh, and I melted away into the feeling. “These are the Sikhs of my Guru, the untutored children of God !”. Seeing them I almost cried, “How good to be Muslims if such sweet love and service is Islam !”

Sikh life cast a halo of spiritual softness, almost that of the Budha’s sculptured face on the Land of the Five Rivers and mellowed down the tone of the very speech of the Muslim. These were the social effects of the Sikh-Muslim School.

Rai Bular, the Bhatti child of Talwandi (now Nanakana) has left behind in the very blood of his offspring a feeling of worship of Guru Nanak.

These followers of Guru Nanak loved the Gurus, served the people, and thought ill of no one. Their universal goodwill, their angelic demeanour, their saintly lives drew an involuntary and silent homage from the people of the Punjab. Even the old Pathans of the Indian Frontier bear witness and say, “The Sikh is a Fakir, his prayers reach God. Bow to him as a man of God whenever you see him”.

The Guru loved the people, made no distinction between the Hindu and the Muslim. It was the spirit of the Guru’s love unshackled by sects and creeds that went deep into the soul of the people.

Invisible transformations were many, but great impetus to a universal friendship between man and man was given by the Guru. He awakened the people to a new spiritual and social consciousness. He awakened individuals to cosmic consciousness. All religions met in the Guru, loosing their names. The past was fulfilled and all the future hovered round the song of the Guru. The “Guru” was thenceforward a whole religion of love, for people. It was a new liberty.

Guru was thenceforward a whole religion of love, for people. It was a new liberty.

A reference to the pure Punjabi literature created by Bullah Shah and Waris Shah would show the atomic structure of its words, that this is the language; of Guru Granth, with an individual note, of rapture from each poet. Particularly the whole tone of Bullah Shah is distinctly of the colour of the Guru. He refers to the transient pleasures of the world as “plucking of Kasumbha flowers”. The Guru also calls them the false dye of Kusumbha as compared with the fast dye of the maddar-root to which the joys of soul are compared.

“The men of deeds , of practice of His presence have crossed the river.

I am left behind, defeated in myself.

I have been picking Kusumbha buds from these fields of life”.

He refers to Simrin as “Spining of cotton yarn” He refers to man as the Bride who is to make preparations here by making sufficient yarn and cloth for her “dowry” and refers to the home after death as the Home of Her Bridegroom. This is exactly in the spirit of the Gurus, in the very same phrase.

“Sat Guru has made me un-manifested manifest me.”

(Sat-Guru nealakh lakhya hai) – is a whole refrain of Bullah’s one poem which reads life a tune taken from Guru Granth. Bullah Shah sings directly out of his soul, but he is truly inspired by the Guru-atmosphere in the Punjab.

Shah Hussain, whose songs are so poignant with aching love for God, is strongly resonant of Guru culture. All great things refuse to be classed. They go everywhere and get classed with everything. But to swing the pendulum is to impart new life to it. Sikhism has been, all along supposed to be a blend of Semitic and Aryan cultures. From my study of Guru Granth, the most authentic record of the Guru’s mind, I can say that it is the historic culmination of Buddha’s religion. the religion of the truly illumined, the truly illumined of all races and countries. Few would deny the true spiritual and human culture first starts from Buddha in this world, it is Buddha’s gospel that in the life of Christ becomes true Christianity1. By Christianity I mean the Religion of Christ himself. “Those who have seen the Son, have seen the Father”. And the Christ’s inspiration gives Islam its humanity. Semitic and Aryan cultures seem to have in animal sacrificing cruelty a common ancestry. Islam in this latter aspect is Vedicism, a dualism and goes to conquer the Kafir like the Aryan of the old conquering the non-Aryan.

Islam by its attitude of conquering others and hating the Kafir and the animal sacrifices in the name of Allah, presents difficulties to the modern thinker. Islam lives in the first great Caliphs. Islam lives now only as an aggression a kin to that of an Empire-maker.

Guru Nanak sympathised with the Muslims in their fall from true Islam into the mad religion of empire-making and crushing their fellow-beings under their heels, and there are many passages in which he as their teacher admonished them back to the right conduct, right feeling and right contemplation. The wise and truly religious therefore, bowed down to the Guru.

The religion of the Gurus thus is the Great Humanity of feeling which makes man good without an effort, and is but a “looking up”, “a gazing up” towards God. Men and women looking up to Him forever, waiting for His coming, opening their mouths like rain-birds to the shower of His Love. A moment comes when by His favour, man is transmuted into a god. And all effort of creation is to produce that great man of God. If any animal is to be sacrificed in love of Him, it is the animal-in-man.

The synthetic blending of things take place in the realms of the intellect; the Guru lives in the soul of the Universe, in the spirit of life, in the labour of Love, in the inebriation of that Great Beautiful. A new present start with the Guru. The future is all his.

  1. These are individual opinions. ↩︎

Deep Sidhu – Essence of Punjab

Deep was a phenomenon that happened with Punjab. there were many colours to his personality. When the news of his death came every one was shocked. I have never seen or heard of this kind of mass grieving taking place. Sikhs all over the world especially youth felt his loss the most. Every one felt that they have lost someone of their own. Why was that? Even people who are not very active in panthic (Sikh religious) circles felt his loss. It was because he was able to connect to every Sikh’s inner self (which even they them selves didn’t knew) when he talked passionately about issues related to Sikhs and Punjab. He took all his inspirations from Sikh history, he connected Sikh youth that had been disconnected from their own roots to their glorious past. His love and passion could be easily felt from his speeches which appealed to inner self of people. Other wise changing people just by speeches is not possible there are lots of good orators around who have good command on the speech but are only speaking through intellect, probably that is the difference between knowledge and wisdom. Knowledge is defined first as the “acquaintance” with facts, truths or principles, as from study or investigation. Knowledge is intellect driven and can be gained from books, news, research etc, but wisdom on the other hand has to do more with insight, understanding and accepting of the fundamental ‘nature’ of things in life. It is full understanding to the soul and feeling fully connected. As prof Puran Singh has correctly stated that Intellectual analysis is never right, perception by the soul is never wrong. Deep had that soul perception.

Intellectual analysis is never right, perception by the soul is never wrong. Deep had that soul perception.

Existential Crisis

When Deep came on to scene during start of farmers protest he made a point that this is not only just the case of three farmers ordinances for Punjab or the case of MSP (minimum support price) this is the case of existential crisis of Punjab. Now this begs a question as to why was it the question of existential crisis or what is existential crisis ?

Answer lies in the Sikh philosophy never to dominate any one and neither to be dominated (ਭੈ ਕਾਹੂ ਕਉ ਦੇਤ ਨਹਿ ਨਹਿ ਭੈ ਮਾਨਤ ਆਨ ॥) that all human beings are created free and equal and any kind of forced domination is totally unacceptable, may that domination could be of any form physical, mental , physiological and these three bills were taking the centre’s domination over the states to next level. Sikhs and Punjab had already been the biased treatment from the centre and these three laws would take it next level. Deep represented what youth of Punjab felt but was not able to express, because of the resentment the people of Punjab had against centre. Punjab had a long history of suffering after 1947 which included:

  1. broken promises by Pt. Jawahar Lal Nehru, struggle to get a Punjabi speaking state post 1947 when rest of India was re-organised on linguistics basis at that time centre not recognising Punjabi as a language and eventually Sikhs had to suffer to pay with their blood to get a Punjabi speaking state from which states like Himachal Pradesh and Haryana were carved out and a very small Punjabi speaking province was created.
  2. In 1984 Central Sanctorum the very heart of Sikhs Sri Harmandir Sahib was attacked by full might of army and resulted in destruction of the temporal authority (Sri Akal Takhat Sahib), then their genocide being committed in November 1984.
  3. Punjab and mainly Sikhs getting subjected to draconian laws such as TADA in 1980’s which resulted in wiping out thousands of Sikhs including young and old men and women in fake police encounters. The human rights activist Sardar Jaswant Singh Khalra who exposed this internationally was also killed.
  4. Punjab had been going though economic genocide as no new industry was encouraged in Punjab to increase its dependency on to centre and to keep Punjab mainly agrarian economy and while keeping Punjab mainly agrarian economy Punjab’s waters were taken illegally from Punjab and was given to Rajasthan, Haryana and Delhi. So Punjab’s farmers had to use ground water for their crops which caused the ground water table of Punjab to go down drastically and as a result Indian Punjab is on the verge or becoming desert.
  5. In 2000’s drugs were specifically introduced in Punjab, which caused most of the youth who survive the period of militancy in Punjab became drug addict.
  6. Lots of Sikh political prisoners have completed their jail sentences but are still languishing in jails for no apparent reason.

Deep didn’t see farmer’s bill in isolation but connected every thing together with the global picture and correctly identified that this is governments next step in the above mentioned things already done and this will the last nail in sealing the fate of people of Punjab because if these bills were to be implemented it would eventually lead to the domination of big corporates over farming and would leave farmers at their mercy and Punjab being agrarian province and majority Sikhs in Punjab are associated with farming, that is why it was existential crises for Punjab and Sikhs as it would take away even the last bit of free will that they have.

He correctly identified that people at the grassroot level are either not aware of the political rights or are not able to express them selves because of the amount of oppression in Punjab for example three Sikh youth were jailed for keeping literature that is perfectly in their democratic rights ( AFDR regrets life term to three youths) Deep stood up and became the voice for all those disenfranchised people who were suffering from State’s oppression and made them aware that this was the case for their existential crises because they are continuously going through a genocide which was going on at all fronts i.e. physical, economic, cultural etc.

Why is Deep a Shaheed (Martyr) for the people of Punjab ?

First lets see what is the definition of Shaheed as per Sikhi, as per Sikhi one who willingly want to play the game of love that person gives up their love for their own life and walk on the path of love.

ਜਿਉ ਤਿਉ ਪ੍ਰੇਮ ਖੇਲਣ ਕਾ ਚਾਉ ॥
ਸਿਰੁ ਧਰਿ ਤਲੀ ਗਲੀ ਮੇਰੀ ਆਉ ॥

As Prof Puran Singh states: Much is in sprouting and more in the seed, and all is in the Guru who made us so to love freedom as to prefer death and dissolution to slavery of the soul. Better wholesale ruination than the extinction of the Guru’s Lamp of Love, lit in the shrine of our hearts. This burning love for freedom in the Sikh soul is bound to make life on this earth full of perils, and any unjust kings and despotic potentates against him; and so it has ever been, also if we look at other Sikh Shaheeds (martyr’s) right from the Guru period till date then we see that they made a conscious decision to proceed on the path of truth shown by Guru out of their love for Guru then to waver from it in any way to save their own skin.

This burning love for freedom in the Sikh soul is bound to make life on this earth full of perils, and any unjust kings and despotic potentates against him

Now if we consider Deep. He came into Sikh struggle from his love for Sikhi & Punjab, by leaving the luxurious life that he was leading in the high rise apartments of Mumbai and driving expensive cars, and dining in the most expensive restaurants. He left his successful career as a corporate lawyer where he had worked with big corporate houses such as Sahara India Pariwar, British law firm Hammonds, and then becoming the legal head of Balaji Telefilms. He selflessly left all that to stand with disenfranchised and marginalised community (Sikhs of Punjab) who had been at the target of state’s oppression from last four decades. He knew the path that he has chosen is full of perils because by doing that he was coming directly in confrontation with state as he was talking about Sikh sovereignty and defended the democratic rights and aspirations of Sikhs for their own independent nation (which are not wrong in any sense ). Deep knew that on this path he could end up loosing his life because he mentioned the same in one of his talks. He knew clearly what he was up against. There were multiple assassination attempts made on him, but he never backed down from the cause he was passionately attached and believed in. He had full faith in Guru Sahib. That is the reason why he is a Sikh Shaheed because he full-filled the definition described about about the Sikh Shaheed that the one who chooses to follow the path of Guru purely out of their love for Guru irrespective of the dangers they might have to face.

In the end I would only say that Deep represented the character sketch of youth correctly predicted by Prof Puran Singh in his poem ਜਵਾਨ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ( Youth of Punjab)

ਇਹ ਬੇਪਰਵਾਹ ਜਵਾਨ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ,
ਮੌਤ ਨੂੰ ਮਖ਼ੌਲਾਂ ਕਰਨ,
ਮਰਨ ਥੀਂ ਨਹੀਂ ਡਰਦੇ ।
ਪਿਆਰ ਨਾਲ ਇਹ ਕਰਨ ਗ਼ੁਲਾਮੀ,
ਜਾਨ ਕੋਹ ਆਪਣੀ ਵਾਰ ਦਿੰਦੇ
ਪਰ ਟੈਂ ਨਾ ਮੰਨਣ ਕਿਸੇ ਦੀ,
ਖਲੋ ਜਾਣ ਡਾਂਗਾਂ ਮੋਢੇ ‘ਤੇ ਉਲਾਰਦੇ ।
ਮੰਨਣ ਬਸ ਇਕ ਆਪਣੀ ਜਵਾਨੀ ਦੇ ਜ਼ੋਰ ਨੂੰ
ਅੱਖੜਖਾਂਦ, ਅਲਬੇਲੇ, ਧੁਰ ਥੀਂ ਸਤਿਗੁਰਾਂ ਦੇ,
ਆਜ਼ਾਦ ਕੀਤੇ ਇਹ ਬੰਦੇ ।
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਨਾ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਨਾ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਨ,
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਸਾਰਾ ਜੀਂਦਾ ਗੁਰੂ ਦੇ ਨਾਮ ‘ਤੇ ।

These carefree young men of Punjab,
they mock death, Not afraid to die.
To do it with love, then they will give their life
They are not enslaved by anyone, Standing up with clubs slung over the shoulders,
Just believe the emphasis of their youth
These stubborn and determined, smart and handsome
These freed (sovereign) men of Guru
Punjab neither Hindu nor Muslim,
The whole Punjab lives in the name of Guru.

– Harpreet Singh